Bill Cosby was convicted Thursday of drugging and molesting a woman in the first big celebrity trial of the #MeToo era, completing the spectacular late-life downfall of a comedian who broke racial barriers in Hollywood on his way to TV superstardom as America’s Dad.
Cosby, 80, could end up spending his final years in prison after a jury concluded he sexually violated Toronto native and Temple University employee Andrea Constand at his suburban Philadelphia home in 2004. He claimed the encounter was consensual.
The verdict came after a two-week retrial in which prosecutors put five other women on the stand who testified that Cosby, married for 54 years, drugged and violated them, too. One of those women asked him through her tears, “You remember, don’t you, Mr. Cosby?”
As It Happens
Cosby accuser credits Andrea Constand’s perseverance, #MeToo for guilty verdict
Cosby stared straight ahead as the verdict was read, but moments later lashed out loudly at District Attorney Kevin Steele and called him an “asshole” after the prosecutor asked that Cosby be immediately jailed because he might flee.
Cosby denied he has an airplane and shouted, “I’m sick of him!”
The judge decided Cosby can remain free on bail while he awaits sentencing.
Shrieks erupted in the courtroom when the verdict was announced, and some of Cosby’s accusers whimpered and cried. Constand remained stoic, then hugged her lawyer and members of the prosecution team.
14 hours of deliberating
The panel of seven men and five women reached a verdict after deliberating 14 hours over two days, vindicating prosecutors’ decision to retry Cosby after his first trial ended with a hung jury less than a year ago.
Cosby could get up to 10 years in prison on each of the three counts of aggravated indecent assault. He is likely to get less than that under state sentencing guidelines, but given his age, even a modest term could mean he will die behind bars.
The time for the defendant to escape justice is over.– Stewart Ryan, prosecutor
Constand, 45, a former Temple women’s basketball administrator, told jurors that Cosby knocked her out with three blue pills he called “your friends” and then penetrated her with his fingers as she lay immobilized, unable to resist or say no.
It was the only criminal case to arise from a barrage of allegations from more than 60 women who said the former TV star drugged and molested them over a span of five decades.
Cosby ‘nothing like’ man on TV
“The time for the defendant to escape justice is over,” prosecutor Stewart Ryan said in his closing argument. “It’s finally time for the defendant to dine on the banquet of his own consequences.”
Another prosecutor, Kristen Feden, said Cosby was “nothing like the image that he played on TV” as sweater-wearing, wisdom-dispensing father of five Dr. Cliff Huxtable on The Cosby Show.
Watch the district attorney take a question on Cosby’s conviction.
Cosby’s retrial took place against the backdrop of #MeToo, the movement against sexual misconduct that has taken down powerful men in rapid succession, among them Harvey Weinstein, Matt Lauer, Kevin Spacey and Sen. Al Franken.
The jurors all indicated they were aware of #MeToo but said before the trial they could remain impartial. Cosby’s lawyers slammed #MeToo, calling Cosby its victim and likening it to a witch hunt or a lynching.
More accusers testified
After failing to win a conviction last year, prosecutors had more courtroom weapons at their disposal for the retrial. The other accusers’ testimony helped move the case beyond a he said, she said, allowing prosecutors to argue that Cosby was a menace to women long before he met Constand. Only one other accuser was permitted to testify at Cosby’s first trial.
Cosby’s new defence team, led by Michael Jackson lawyer Tom Mesereau, launched a highly aggressive attack on Constand and the other women.
Their star witness, a longtime Temple employee, testified that Constand once spoke of setting up a prominent person and suing. Constand sued Cosby after prosecutors initially declined to file charges, settling with him for nearly $3.4 million US over a decade ago.
“You’re dealing with a pathological liar,” Mesereau told the jury.
His colleague on the defence team, Katheen Bliss, derided the other accusers as homewreckers and suggested they made up their stories in a bid for money and fame.
But Cosby himself had long ago confirmed sordid revelations about drugs and extramarital sex.
In a deposition he gave over a decade ago as part of Constand’s lawsuit, Cosby acknowledged he had obtained qualudes to give to women he wanted to have sex with, “the same as a person would say, ‘Have a drink.”‘ The sedative was a popular party drug before the U.S. banned it more than 30 years ago.
Cosby also acknowledged giving pills to Constand before their sexual encounter. But he identified them as the over-the-counter cold and allergy medicine Benadryl and insisted they were meant to help her relax.
It’s a victory for womanhood and all sexual assault survivors — female and male.– Lili Bernard, Cosby accuser
After the verdict was announced, the district attorney praised Constand, saying, “She was that first courageous person that stood up in public to go to the authorities and say that Bill Cosby drugged and sexually assaulted her.”
Constand stood alongside the lawyers who prosecuted the case and listened as Steele praised her “quiet courage.”
“I think now there’s tremendous awareness of how these crimes have been covered up and papered over for years,” he said. “And I hope and I pray that our actions have shown that we will stand up with those victims.”
Meserau, one of Cosby’s lawyers, said “we are very disappointed by the verdict” and that they don’t believe their client is guilty of anything.
“The fight is not over.”
‘Justice has been done’
Some of Cosby’s accusers were at the courthouse as the verdict was issued.
“It’s a victory for womanhood and all sexual assault survivors — female and male,” said Lili Bernard, an artist and actor who has also made accusations against Cosby.
“I thank the jury so much for positioning themselves on the right side of history.”
Gloria Allred, a lawyer for many of Cosby’s accusers, thanked the jury and said “justice has been done.”
She said the accusers she represents have been speaking out for several years, and that many weren’t believed at the beginning.
The women faced smears, denigration and attempts to discredit them, she said.
“The jury in this second criminal trial found that they believed women, and I’m the happiest I have been about any court decision in 42 years.”
Allred, standing alongside some of Cosby’s accusers, praised Constand and other women who came forward for taking on the risks associated with speaking out.
“The #metoo movement has arrived, and is well,” she said.
She closed her remarks by saying she had three words for Cosby.
“Guilty, guilty, guilty.”
The entertainer broke racial barriers as the first black actor to star in a network show, I Spy, in the 1960s. He created the top-ranked Cosby Show two decades later. He also found success with his Fat Albert animated TV show and served as pitchman for Jello-O pudding.
Later in his career, he attracted controversy for lecturing about social dysfunction in poor black neighbourhoods, railing against young people stealing things and wearing baggy pants.
It was Cosby’s reputation as a public moralist that prompted a federal judge, acting in response to a request from The Associated Press, to unseal portions of the deposition.
Its release helped destroy The Cosby Show star’s career and good guy image. It also prompted authorities to reopen the criminal investigation, and he was charged in late 2015.
The Associated Press does not typically identify people who are victims of sexual assault unless they grant permission. Constand has done so.