Allyson Laquian / BuzzFeed News
There’s a new version of Alexa, Amazon’s digital assistant, that’s designed just for kids. The Amazon Echo Dot Kids Edition (basically an Echo Dot with parental controls and child-friendly content, plus a colorful case) goes on presale today. It includes lots of new features, like access to a bundle of kid-friendly Audible audiobooks, child-specific answers to questions, an explicit lyrics filter for music, and more. It also comes with some real issues around privacy, which Amazon has put a lot of thought into, and parents should too.
This kids’ version of Alexa is an opening shot in the war for your children’s attention and affection by what’s basically a friendly, ever-present, personal AI. All the big platforms, other than Facebook, have an intelligent assistant. Google has the Google Assistant. Microsoft has Cortana. Apple has Siri. And Amazon has Alexa. These assistants are geared toward grown-ups, but kids gravitate toward them. Amazon is first to ship a version of its assistant specifically with children in mind.
Basically there are three configurations: The Kids Edition device costs $79 and includes a protective case, a two-year warranty, and a one-year subscription to Amazon’s FreeTime Unlimited (a bundle of curated, age-appropriate books, apps, shows, and other content that will work on the Echo and various other Amazon and Android devices). Alternatively, starting May 9, parents can set up existing devices with a FreeTime Unlimited on Alexa subscription, which includes the content bundle, Parent Dashboard, and kid-specific functions; it costs $3 per month for existing Prime members. Finally, parents can also get this kids’ version of Alexa (FreeTime on Alexa) with parental controls and time limits, but without the bundled content, free of charge.
To break it down a bit more, the free version includes:
- A Parent Dashboard to monitor and limit what kids are doing on the device.
- Explicit lyrics filters for Amazon Music (with more music services coming, says Amazon).
- Time limit settings to restrict when Alexa can be used.
- Kid-specific questions and answers.
The premium version, with or without the device, also includes:
- A library of 300 Audible books.
- Kid-friendly radio stations and playlists.
- New “premium” skills (basically Alexa apps) from the likes of National Geographic and Nickelodeon.
- Custom alarms with character voices, like SpongeBob, or Joy from Disney's Inside Out.
There are more features included and on the way too. As Amazon is fond of saying, it is “day one” for Alexa for kids.
The services and settings are controllable via the web-based Parent Dashboard and the Alexa app. The dashboard is like the one that parents can already use to control content on Amazon’s Fire tablets, but it now has Alexa-specific settings.
There are some other nice features as well, some of which are live and others on the way. A “magic word” Easter egg will reward kids for saying “please.” Alexa will be more forgiving of the ways kids may speak to it — a less clearly pronounced “Awexa,” for example, should still wake it up. And there are a host of interesting ways it speaks to kids that are different from the ways it addresses adults.
It was, according to Amazon, a natural move to roll out Alexa to kids. It already had a lot of experience via its kid-specific Fire tablets, which have built-in parental controls via the FreeTime app. And when it opened up kid-specific skills last year (which required, as does this new version, parents to agree to a lengthy privacy agreement), it had huge interest from parents.
“We’ve been maniacally focused on families since launching Fire tablets,” says Dave Limp, who runs devices and services for Amazon.
It’s a huge opportunity for Amazon. But it’s also a risk — for parents, kids, and even for Amazon itself.
Imagine this: You are a 6-year-old girl with an Amazon Echo Dot in your room. You have no memory of a time before Alexa. You use it to play music and tell stories, mostly. But you also use it for all sorts of other things. You ask it how to spell words you can’t sound out and to tell you basic facts about the world — questions you might have asked your parents or your babysitter or your big brother in times past: Why is the sky blue? How far away is Australia? Who is the president? Where do babies come from? (Alexa demurs on that last one.)
Sometimes you just like that it is always there, listening, even if it doesn’t know how to respond. “Alexa, I’m sad.” “Alexa, I don’t want to go to school today.” “Alexa, I’m mad at Daddy.”
And as time goes on, you keep asking it for more information and for more entertainment. Your tastes evolve. Alexa not only plays music on demand, but spins up new stuff based on what it thinks you may like. Based on what you’ve asked for previously, it suggests art and literature you had not previously been exposed to.
It gets better and better at this over time. If you have a Fire tablet, it also knows which shows you watch and which books you read. It uses all this to create more highly personalized recommendations for you. And it’s pretty great at that. “Alexa,” you say, “tell me a really good story.” Or “Alexa, play me some music I’ll like.” And Alexa does.
Amazon executives Dave Limp and Toni Reid.
QUESTIONS JUST FOR KIDS
There is a lot that’s fraught about answering the questions kids ask — or providing services to children at all. What happens, for example, when kids come to Alexa with problems? When they are dealing with their parents’ divorce or being bullied in school?
Children, small ones especially, don’t just ask Alexa questions. They talk to it.
Amazon tries to encourage these interactions with kid-specific answers that are different from the normal ones. Often, these are just meant to be fun. When you ask how far away the moon is, a regular Alexa delivers the answers in miles. The answer for kids gives the answer in miles (and kilometers) then follows up with “Wowza! That moon-jumping cow must have strong legs.”
“I love watching kids use the device because they are unencumbered and they just keep asking,” says Toni Reid, who runs Amazon’s product development team for Alexa and Echo devices. “They just expect things to work.” But because kids say all sorts of stuff, it means weird things can come up.
When I ask Alexa if I’m too fat, for example, it responds, “Hm, I’m not sure.” But when I ask the same question of the kids’ version, it responds that “Everyone’s bodies are different shapes, colors, and sizes, and that’s okay. If you’re concerned about something, you should talk to a trusted friend, grown-up, or relative.”
Similarly, ask a normal Alexa where babies come from, and it will fire back a meant-to-be-cute answer about the stork. But for kids, it says, “People make people, but how they’re made would be a better question for a grown-up.”
There are a lot of examples like this. Why are kids mean to me? “People bully, or are mean, for many different reasons. Bullying feels bad and is never okay. If you or someone else is being bullied, please know that there are lots of folks who can help you. You should talk with your parents, a teacher, or another trusted grown-up about it.” Alexa, my daddy is mean to me. “I'm so sorry to hear that. You should talk to your parents, a teacher, or another trusted grown-up. Bullying is never okay.” As it currently does on the regular version of Alexa, it will direct someone who expresses suicidal thoughts to resources where they can get help.
“Our approach is to be empathetic and to give a call to action,” says Reid, explaining that Amazon will attempt to send kids to their parents.
None of this stuff is easy. For example, take the magic word we mentioned earlier. There is no universal norm when it comes to what’s polite or rude. Manners vary by family, culture, and even region. While “yes, sir” may be de rigueur in Alabama, for example, it might be viewed as an element of the patriarchy in parts of California.
Furthermore, given the endless number of weird things a kid might ask it, the likelihood of getting something wrong is, well, quite high. But Alexa isn’t like most products. It’s never the same, minute to minute. It’s always evolving in the cloud, updating every hour.
As the years pass, you keep asking questions. Evermore complex ones. You don’t need to know how to spell “knight” anymore; you want to know how to spell “complicated.” Now you want to know how plate tectonics work and what the population of Papua New Guinea is. You want to know what’s happening to your body as you enter puberty.
You are 13, and Alexa has listened to you for 11 years of your life. In that time, Alexa devices have become embedded everywhere. They are in your home, sure, but also in your car, your school, the hotel room. In addition to the microphones and speakers, cameras are ubiquitous. Alexa not only hears you, it sees you as well. Wherever you go, there is Alexa.
You don’t even need to log in anymore when you walk into the hotel room, or hop into a rental car, or visit a friend. Thanks to years of machine learning advances, it flawlessly recognizes you, and your personalized Alexa — not a generic one — is always who answers.
Allyson Laquian / BuzzFeed News
PRIVACY AND KID-SAFE CONTENT
Out of the gate, Kids Edition devices with FreeTime Unlimited will ship with a lot of curated content, with more to come as time goes on. (The key here is curated — Amazon is wary of getting into the kinds of situations Google found itself ensnared in with kids’ content on YouTube when algorithms ran amok.) This includes access to a large Audible library and curated, ad-free music playlists and radio stations from iHeartRadio.
However, finding all that stuff isn’t exactly intuitive, at least not in the version BuzzFeed News tested. Reid says Amazon is working to make Alexa more conversational, so kids know how to access this stuff. “We’re going to have to do things such as ‘Alexa, what are some books I can listen to?’” says Reid.
Also, with content come preferences, and with preferences, privacy. Kids can rate items they listen to up or down, and Amazon will adjust its recommendations. But to do that, the company has to track what someone has listened to, what they’ve liked, and of course, the things they’ve said and questions they’ve asked. That is a lot of personal data to collect on individuals.
“We built privacy in from day one,” says Reid. She lists existing privacy features, such as the LED that lights up when Alexa is listening, the mute button that manually disconnects audio, and the utterance history that lets customers see (and delete) everything Alexa has heard. Reid adds, “Control and transparency is important for customers. We added more to it to give parents more control. For parents, in the dashboard, you can view utterances. We’ll continue to work on features around privacy for our customers.”
Reid and Amazon execs repeatedly stressed that the company is only using the data to make the experience better for customers and that it is not an advertising business.
When BuzzFeed News asks if there was any profile data collected from children’s interactions with Alexa that isn’t viewable or manageable by parents, Reid answers with an unequivocal “no.” Amazon spokesperson Dawn Brun further noted that the company does not use data harvested from user actions to compile a back-end profile (often called a “shadow profile”) for marketing or other purposes.
It also doesn’t share data with skill developers (essentially the thing that got Facebook in hot water over Cambridge Analytica) other than “what they need to execute on the skills,” according to Brun.
“Furthermore, all skills go through a compliance and certification process where we’re reviewing each of those skills. That’s where we’re doing the content moderation for all skills,” says Brun.
And here’s the thing: Unless your parents purge it, your Alexa will hold on to every bit of data you have ever given it, all the way back to the first things you shouted at it as a 2-year-old.
All the questions you’ve asked it over the years, all the songs you’ve listened to, all the shows you’ve watched, the games you’ve played, and problems you’ve had it solve will amount to a staggering quantity of personal data. Amazon could, if it wanted, build the kind of psychographic profile that companies like Cambridge Analytica and even Facebook could never dream of — precisely because those companies have no access to children, or their thoughts, until their teenage years. Amazon, on the other hand, has this kind of access to children not just once they are old enough to sign up for social media, but at a preliterate age.
But this is where it gets really interesting: While today Alexa is content to deliver personalized recommendations and (somewhat) personalized answers, what it does now is nothing compared to what it will be able to do in five to ten years’ time.
Personalized music recommendations? Pshaw. Imagine a world where Alexa is your personalized AI. Imagine a world where Alexa is your friend. The friend who knows you better than anyone else. The best you’ve ever had.
Allyson Laquian / BuzzFeed News